The first time, I was 15 and also definitely disliked it. I believed Holden was such a loser. At 33, I read it once more, as well as still believed it was extremely overrated. This past summer season, 20 years later on, I review it once more.
I can tell you why I disliked the book at both 15 and The reason I disliked it was the whole novel is created from the viewpoint of a teenager, Holden, which is immature, snotty, adverse, whiney, and also just annoying as heck. The voice that narrates the unique resonates immaturity and also the simplicity of his whining is godawful but fairly necessary for the impact of the plot. The language, however, seems specifically like a teen who has actually lost his way complete with insightfulness, sincerity, and also confusion as he attempts to make it via secondary school.
Holden is not really a pleasant personality, but his message requires to be listened to. After reviewing it, I decided it would certainly be needed analysis in my AP class. Salinger catches this in a significant method. Individuals slam the book as an outcome of Caulfield is entirely unlikable, a guy THAT rails versus phonies when he himself are some points of a phony … nevertheless that belongs of the objective. Holden shakes off all the signals someone in his state of events actually shakes off in real life, and also instead like real life, they are almost constantly unheeded.
Plainly this was a truly, horribly autobiographical benefitSalinger Download J. There square step numerous minutes when Caulfield, telling within the individual, states offhandedly that he started to weep, he did not realize why, he seemed like passing away, and also unexpectedly it disappeared and also he really felt rejuvenated with power. It sounds extremely real. THAT created these products with such sincerity in ?
THAT took on these issues, and also in such a style, within the s? You which i understanding Holden Caulfield. We have actually much- well known that individual. And also within the Catcher within the Rye, you reach look within his mind. Stradlater teases Holden, who flies into a craze and assaults Stradlater. Stradlater pins Holden down and bloodies his nose.
On the train to New york city, Holden fulfills the mom of one of his fellow Pencey students. When he reaches Penn Terminal, he enters into a phone booth as well as considers calling a number of individuals, however, for numerous factors he chooses versus it.
He gets in a taxi and also asks the taxi driver where the ducks in Central Park go when the shallows ices up, but his concern annoys the motorist. Holden has the cab driver take him to the Edmont Hotel, where he inspects himself in.
From his area at the Edmont, Holden could see into the areas of a few of the guests in the opposite wing. Salinger captures the bitterly confused mind of a youth WHO hates the full world not as a result of the globe is value hating, however as a result of he is pissed off at his own inability to urge on therein world, with such crisp reality that it shocks much more than any fantastical yankee diseased person. Reading over the negative reviews on Amazon, i can not facilitate however surprise however and why such a big amount of individuals square measure therefore unable to urge it.
The Catcher within the Rye is among the, if not the, most tangibly realistic appearance into the mind of a malcontent, disenchanted youth plagued by depression and slightly of the bipolar. He thinks he is higher than the globe, and he thinks he is the lousiest person within the world at a similar time.
He desires everybody to travel away and leave him alone, and he cannot bear anyone, not even some schmo he very dislikes with sensible reason , to go away him.
Salinger captures this in a tremendous approach. People criticize the book as a result of Caulfield is completely unlikable, a man WHO rails against phonies once he himself are some things of a phony … however that is a part of the purpose. Holden throws off all the signals somebody in his state of affairs really throws off in real world, and rather like real world, they are nearly always unheeded.
Clearly this was a really, terribly autobiographical work for Salinger. Download J. There square measure many moments once Caulfield, narrating within the person, mentions offhandedly that he began to cry, he did not grasp why, he felt like dying, and suddenly it went away and he felt reinvigorated with energy.
It rings remarkably true. WHO wrote these items with such honesty in ?
0コメント